I love barbecue. And let’s be clear: when I say “barbecue” I don’t mean burgers on the grill. Hell, I don’t mean anything on the grill, really. Grilling does not equal barbecuing. Both do involve fire, and both (usually) involve meat. Real ‘cue needs smoke. This is where the two part ways. And none of this really matters, because I don’t have a smoker, nor do I have the hours and hours required to properly prepare pig parts for ‘cuing.
What I do have is a slow cooker. A nice, 6-quart capacity slow cooker that I use far too rarely – until today. The corner market & butcher was having a run on pork butt (tee-hee) for a buck a pound, which made me wonder what exactly I could make with about 3 bucks worth of pig. Easy-peasy answer: pulled pork sandwiches.
You’ll need:
1 big ol’ white onion, sliced
3-4 lbs. Pork shoulder or butt (tee-hee)
So far, so good – right? Here’s where personal preference comes into play. What type of pulled pork to pick? The sweet, tangy red sauce of traditional barbecue? The mustardy, vinegar-y Carolina school of bbq? I kinda opted for both, mixed with the “what do I have in the fridge” approach.
I whisked together some cider vinegar, two teaspoons of Dijon mustard, ketchup, hot sauce, a tablespoon of brown sugar, and a touch of bottled BBQ sauce. Purists will argue that no bottled sauce should ever get near good BBQ, but since this is make-it-up-as-you-go BBQ, it should be okay.

Then I set the sauce in the fridge for the flavors to hang out and get to know each other overnight. Not much is needed, maybe a half cup of this sauce when all is said and done – it’s just to flavor the meat a bit while it cooks. And remember: No Liquid Smoke. That’s cheating.
Slice the white onion and cover the bottom of the slow cooker. This is like a bed for the pork. Any leftover onion not needed to cover the bottom I just quartered and put in around the meat. Your pork will benefit from some space – if you have a whole uncut piece of meat, give it a slice and spread it out a bit throughout the cooker. Taking the extra time to cube the meat is sometimes suggested, but I like nice long strands of pork – cutting it too much prevents that.
When the pork is in the cooker, pour your homemade sauce over the pork. Now, like the man says: set it and forget it. Anywhere from 8-12 hours on low will take care of the cooking process. Simple enough, correct? Like the title says, I’ve Never Made This Before…so the easier, the better.
After cooking, remove the meat and let it rest on a cutting board. Discard the onion and juices in the bottom of the cooker. Pull apart meat with two forks and return to slow cooker. Pour in anywhere from 12-18oz. of your favorite BBQ sauce, homemade or bottled. In a perfect world, my well-smoked pulled pork wouldn’t need sauce at all – the sweet smoked meat would be all I’d need. As it is…the more sauce, the better. Give it another half hour on high to incorporate the liquid and reduce the sogginess factor.
The Verdict: Not bad. Not perfect, but again, I don’t have a smoker outside my back door. But it’s a good stopgap when one feels the need for BBQ, and if nothing else it’s cheap.
Tags: barbecue, pulled pork, slow cooker